Articles

2018 Review: South Scotland

In News on July 30, 2016 by dadge Tagged: ,

South Renfrewshire 77180
Paisley 77920*
Inverclyde 75885* (includes NP06 Ferguslie Park 2380)
North Cunninghame 76827
South Cunninghame 72365
Kilmarnock & Cumnock 71824
Ayr 73853

scots

Dumfries & Galloway 76394* (includes East Dumfries part of Lochar ward 09A2/B2/H3 3192)
Roxburgh, Selkirk & Annandale 72456*
East Lothian 76153
Berwick & Peebles 71570
Midlothian 73173* (includes Craigmillar)
Edinburgh East 71944*
Leith & Queensferry 77438*
Edinburgh South 75334
Edinburgh West 74294* (includes Hillside)

edin plan

Articles

2018 Review: North Scotland

In News on July 29, 2016 by dadge Tagged:

scotn

Caithness, Sutherland & Cromarty 77938
Ross, Skye & Inverness 76334
Argyll & Bute 73889
Banff & Buchan 77582
Moray 78294*
Gordon 74328* (includes Rothiemay and Grange)
Aberdeen North 78274
Aberdeen South 71961
Montrose 76952
Forfar 77988
Dundee 76317
Perth 72831
South Tay 75957
Glenrothes & Kinross 75077
Kirkcaldy & Cowdenbeath 73323
Dunfermline 78254

* estimate

scotm

 

Edit: Alternative arrangement for North East Scotland

scotlandne

Elgin & Banff 78389

Buchan & Formartine 73634

Marr 78181

Articles

2018 Review: Scotland

In News on July 29, 2016 by dadge Tagged:

Scotland is a different proposition from England and Wales. The Scottish boundary commission have a very different attitude from their southern counterparts. They prioritise respect for local-authority boundaries, and to that end they split as many wards as necessary. To begin with they split their task up into groups of council areas, and I have done so as follows:

Highland, Argyll, Moray: 4:08 > 4 seats
Aberdeenshire, Angus, Dundee: 5.07 > 5 seats
Aberdeen: 1.99 > 2 seats
Perth, Fife: 4.98 > 5 seats
Stirling, Clackmannan, Falkirk, North & South Lanark, West Lothian: 11.12 > 11 seats
West & East Dunbartonshire: 1.98 > 2 seats
Glasgow: 5.92 > 6 seats
North, East & South Ayrshire, Inverclyde, Renfrew & East Renfrew: 6.98 > 7 seats
Edinburgh, Midlothian, Borders, Dumfries & Galloway: 7.86 > 8 seats
East Lothian: 1.01 > 1 seat

There’s a slight imbalance between the groupings, especially a one-ward imbalance between the Central and Edinburgh areas, but the boundaries between the areas can be crossed if necessary. The same goes for Glasgow, which could take in a ward from outside the city, possibly Stathkelvin or Giffnock, but it’s good to avoid this if possible.

scot areas te s

There is an alternative arrangement in the south of Scotland as follows:
Stirling, Clackmannan, Falkirk, North & South Lanark, Renfrew & East Renfrew: 11.95 > 12 seats
Dumfries & Galloway, North, East & South Ayrshire, Inverclyde: 5.95 > 6 seats
Edinburgh, Mid & West Lothian, Borders: 8.06 > 8 seats
This has a better balance of electorates but I’ve found it more difficult as a basis for creating good constituencies, so for the tme being I’m sticking with the first set of groupings above.

Articles

2018 Review: South Wales

In News on July 26, 2016 by dadge Tagged: , , ,

I’ve had a lot of “fun” with South Wales. There are several complex subareas:
– Neath, Port Talbot, Bridgend and Ogmore
– Rhondda Cynon Taf
– Caerphilly, Merthyr and Blaenau Gwent
– Newport
and my plan is one of many reasonable solutions to the constiuency map of Glamorgan and Gwent.

wales s

Gower 73525
Swansea 78192
Ogmore & Aberavon 75955
Neath 78463
Bridgend 74335
Cardiff West 75563
Cardiff North 78187
Cardiff East 74128
Barry 76984
Rhondda & Aberdare 77674
Pontypridd 78033
Caerphilly 76429
Merthyr & Rhymney 75250
Newport 72537
Blaenau Gwent 72958
Torfaen 77367
Monmouth 78101

Articles

2018 Review: Mid Wales

In News on July 21, 2016 by dadge Tagged:

wales m

Powys 76254
Ceredigion & Preseli 76978
Pembroke 77942
Llanelli & Carmarthen 76985
Cwm Twrch 74948

Articles

2018 Review: North Wales

In News on July 21, 2016 by dadge Tagged:

The North Wales region is just about doable without adding any of Powys, but it would mean seven very small seats, thereby increasing the size of the seats throughout the rest of the country. So it seems only fair to add a small area, either Llanrhaeadr ym Mochnant or Machynlleth. The relative electorates are 2551 and 3927, so the former, as well as being badly linked by road, is hardly worth adding.

wales n

Môn & Ogwen 71398
Eryri 71551
Conwy 72869
Denbigh 72364
Flint 73926
Wrexham Maelor 71501
Alyn & Llangollen 71444

Articles

2018 Review: Hertfordshire

In News on July 19, 2016 by dadge Tagged: ,

11 seats

hertsjul

Watford 73657
Hertsmere 72622
Hemel Hempstead 72739* includes polling district DAA (Primrose Hill) 1998 voters
Three Rivers 72752*
St Albans & Hatfield 77528
Broxbourne 72682
Hertford 71138
North West Hertfordshire 71885
Hitchin & Letchworth 72098
Stevenage 71545
North East Hertfordshire 72584

Hertfordshire in 1899